I Broke 11 Images On Purpose. Which AI Fixes Them? (Krea 3 vs GPT Image 2.5 vs Nano Banana 2 + 4)

I broke 11 images on purpose (extra hands, a third leg, the same person twice, seven fingers, too many sunglasses and lots of typos) and gave them to 7 AI image editors to fix: Krea 3, GPT Image 2.5, Nano Banana 2, Seedream 5, Flux 3, Grok Imagine and Ideogram 4.5. Same image, same prompt, one try each. Four rounds: body horror, clones + a spelling bee (22 misspelled words), simple swaps (shirt colour, logo, bike to car), and the photocopy test: the same face edited five times in a row to see which models slowly destroy it. Then the final tier list. Not sponsored. All models were run on Artlist (it has all seven in one place), and Krea also on its own website, krea.ai. Do you agree with the tier list? Which image editor are you using, and what should I test next? Tell me in the comments. TIER LIST: SS Ideogram 4.5 | S GPT Image 2.5, Grok Imagine | A Flux 3 | B Krea 3, Seedream 5 | C Nano Banana 2 CHAPTERS 0:00 Intro 0:36 The 7 contestants 0:53 The test: 11 broken images 1:22 Round 1: body horror 2:06 Round 2: clones + spelling bee 2:56 Round 3: swaps 3:28 Round 4: 5 edits in a row (photocopy test) 4:21 Tier list 5:06 Do you agree? #AIImageEditor #AITools #Krea #GPTImage #NanoBanana #Ideogram #TierList