Apostate Prophet FIRES BACK at Muslim Debater’s Free Will Defense in HEATED Debate!

Is Islam true? In this Modern Day Debate exchange hosted by James, ex-Muslim critic Ridvan Aydemir, better known as Apostate Prophet, faces Dr. Abdul Majid in a debate over the foundations of Islam. This video focuses on one of the most discussed sections of the debate: the Islamic doctrine of divine decree, known as qadar, and whether it can be reconciled with human free will, moral responsibility and the idea of eternal punishment. In his opening statement, Apostate Prophet argues that Islam rests on three foundations: Allah, Muhammad and the Quran. He points to Quran 51:56, which says Allah created humans to worship Him, and Quran 7:179, which says Allah created many among mankind for hell. He also cites verses stating that Allah guides and misguides whom He wills and that no soul can believe except by Allah's permission. His question is direct: if Allah created, designed and decreed everything, how can people be held responsible for a disbelief that was written before they were born? Dr. Abdul Majid responds that Allah gave every person eyes, ears and a mind to recognize the truth, and that people choose their own path. He compares the situation to a university that clearly explains its rules before students enroll, and he cites Surah Hud 11:119 to argue that Allah did not create anyone for hell. He also argues that the Quran must be understood in Arabic and through classical commentary rather than English translation. In the open dialogue, Apostate Prophet asks a series of yes or no questions. Did Allah create everything? Did Allah design everything? Did Allah decree everything before it happened? Is anything outside of Allah's creation and decree? Dr. Abdul Majid agrees with each premise. The discussion then turns to whether belief and disbelief are the person's decision or Allah's decree. Dr. Abdul Majid introduces a distinction between a script and a transcript, questions the use of hypotheticals, and eventually states that belief is Allah's decree, while